Our Salad and Entree Display Always Has Something To Fulfill Your Cravings
NWI's Best Bakery for Over 30 Years
Our Salad and Entree Display Always Has Something To Fulfill Your Cravings
Welcome to Butterfingers Bakery
Pastry Perfection
Craving something sweet? We’ve got you covered. Our display cases are always full of delicious cupcakes, flavored bars, cookies and more to keep your sweet tooth happy.
Call our Highland store for information on current pastry offerings or to place an order for any pastries we do not have in our display case currently.
Freshly Baked Bread Daily: Baked and Sealed In Store to Seal In Freshness
Menu / Price List
Cakes, Cheesecakes & Pies
8 Inch: Serves 10-12
Double Chocolate Mousse Cake
45
Carrot Cake
40
Banana Cake
38
Vanilla Layer Cake
38
Coconut Layer Cake
40
Lemon Layer Cake
38
German Chocolate Cake
45
Sour Cream Fudge Cake
40
Red Velvet Cake
38
Lemon Raspberry Cake
40
Strawberry Cream Cake
40
Raspberry Pound Cake
34
Amaretto Pound Cake
34
Lemon Blueberry Poundcake
34
Cinnamon Almond Coffee Cake
35
Sour Cream, Raspberry Swirl, Marble or Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
45
Blueberry or Cherry Pie
26
Celebration Cakes
10 Inch: Serves 16-20
Carrot Cake
60
Banana Cake
60
Red Velvet Cake
60
Vanilla or Chocolate Cake
60
Sheet Cakes
Serves 25-30
Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Carrot, Lemon or Banana Cake w Cream Cheese
Rapberry Cream Cheese, Whipped Cream, Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream
Small Desserts
Cream Horns
4.95
Vanilla, Chocolate or Strawberry
Cannoli
4.95
Mini Cannoli
2.50
Cookies
.99 Each
Chocolate Chip, M&M Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter Chocolate
Dbl Chocolate, Dried Cranberry White Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Butterscotch
Peanut Butter, Oreo White Chocolate Chunk, Sugar Cookie
Cupcakes
Small Cupcakes: 3.75. Large Cupcakes: 4.75
Banana, Chocolate Cream Filled, Oreo, Vanilla, Lemon, Red Velvet, Reeses
Strawberry, Confetti, Vanilla or Chocolate with Chocolate Buttercream
Boston Cream, Blueberry
Brownies and Bars
3.75 Each
Double Fudge, Fudge Walnut, Cream Cheese, Red Velvet Cream Cheese
Souffle, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Truffle Brownies, Almond/Lemon Bars
Bread, Croissants and Muffins
Butter Croissant
Large: 1.49 | Mini : .99
Bread Loaves
4.95
Cracked Wheat, Sourdough, Italian
Filled Croissants
3.50
Almond, Chocolate, Maple Pecan, Cream Cheese, Strawberry Cream Cheese, Blueberry Cream Cheese
Muffins
3.25
Blueberry, Cranberry Orange, Carrot Nut & Raisin
Sandwiches
Full: 7.50 | Half: 5.25
Bread Options
Croissant, Bread, Pretzel Bun, Tomato Basil Wrap
Meat Options
Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Ham Salad, Turkey, Ham, Italian Meats, Roast Beef
Vegetarian
8
Yellow & Red Peppers, Spinach, Tomato, Cucumber tossed in a Sun-Dried Tomato Dressing
Cheese
Provolone, Pepper-Jack, Cheddar or Swiss
Toppings
Lettuce, Spinach, Tomato, Banana Peppers, Red Onion, Cucumber, Pickle, Jalapeno, Mayo or Chipotle Mayo, Honey or Yellow Mustard, Oil & Vinegar, Italian Seasoning
Garden Salads
Large: 9.50 | Small :6.50
Meats, Cheeses and Toppings can be chosen from Sandwich List Above
Dressings
Buttermilk Ranch, Sun-Dried Tomato, Italian, Oil & Vinegar, Balsamic
Bag and Box Lunches
Bag Lunch
12
Large Sandwich, Small Meatless Salad, Chips
Box Lunch
14
Large Sandwich, Small Meatless Salad, 2 cookies or 1 brownie
Quiche
Ham & Swiss, Broccoli & Cheddar, Spinach & Feta, Broccoli & Red Pepper, Vegetable, Lorraine, Bacon and Ham with Cheddar
Slice
4.50
Half
10.50
Whole
19.50
Sweet Trays
Add a description about this category
Brownie & Bar Trays
Small Tray (48 Pcs) : $50 | Large Tray (96 pc) $95
Cookie Trays
Small Tray - 3 Dozen Cookies: $40 | Large Tray - 6 Dozen Cookies: $75
Cookie and Brownie Tray
Small Tray (2 Dozen Cookies & 15 Pieces) $45 | Large Tray ( 4 Dozen Cookies & 40 Pieces) $90
Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Individual Berries: $2 | 12 inch Tray $57
All White, All Semi-Sweet, Half and Half
Party Trays
Fruit Tray
55
16 inch - Feeds Approx. 20-25
Vegetable Tray & Buttermilk Ranch with Dill
55
16 inch - serves Approx. 20-25
Sandwich Trays
16 inch (12 Half Sandwiches) : 65 | 18 inch (20 Half Sandwiches) 107
Made with your choice of Sandwiches
Salads
Chicken
12.50/ lb
with or without almonds
Tuna
12.75/lb
Ham
10.75/lb
Seafood/ Spicy Seafood
12.25/ lb
Fresh Fruit
10/lb
Asiago Pasta
9/ lb
Red Bliss Potato
10/ lb
Macaroni Pasta
8.75/ lb
Spinach Pasta
9/ lb
Italian Pasta
9 / lb
Pasta Primavera
9.50 /lb
Garden Vegetable
9.50/ lb
Chicken Pasta
10.75/ lb
New Potato with Asparagus or Basil
9.50/ lb
Turkey, Cheese & Red Grape
11.75
Bowtie Asparagus Pasta
10.75/ lb
Napa Cabbage Slaw
8.75/ lb
Broccoli Cranberry
9.50 /lb
First ItemPasta Shells w Mozzarella and Basil
10.50/lb
Greek
11.50/lb
Cucumber Dill
9/ lb
Kale Salad w Strawberries & Goat Cheese
10.50 /lb
Creamy Cole Slaw
8.50
Shaved Brussel Sprouts
10/ lb
Entrees
Chicken
11/ lb
Cilantro Lime, Greek, Bruschetta, Sun-Dried Tomato & Pesto, or Sour Cream and Breadcrumbs
Stuffed Red Peppers
10/ lb
Spinach or Cheese Ravioli
10.50 / lb
Pork Tenderloin with Apricot Mustard
12.50/ lb
Mac n Cheese
10.50/ lb
BBQ Beef
12 / lb
Marinara or BBQ Meatballs
12 / lb
Add a footnote if this applies to your business
Locations
Crown Point
213 N. Main St. Crown Point, IN 46307
(219) 213-2713
Highland
2552 45th St. Highland, IN 46322
(219) 924-6464
Munster
921 Ridge Road, Munster, IN 46321
(219) 836-4202
We're Hiring!
Join Our Team
If you're interested in one of our open positions, start by applying here and attaching your resume.
Welcome visitors & announce promotions
Welcome visitors & announce promotions
Welcome visitors & announce promotions
Welcome visitors & announce promotions
Welcome visitors & announce promotions
Welcome visitors & announce promotions
Copyright © 2025 Butterfingers Bakery NWI - All Rights Reserved.
This website uses cookies.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.